[SIZE=3]
Azrael Zell and Capital Punishment
[/SIZE]
Even a long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away one could find themselves surrounded by simpletons. Azrael Zell, a man forged from the fires of experience and with a vision that included none of the self delusions that plague so much of sentient life, found himself amid such an array of simpletons thus validating his long-held belief that while the probability of human life developing separately and independently in another far off galaxy many eons from now was low, if such a thing ever came to be, he was sure, it would be a planet of idiots.
He reflected on the strange set of events that now saw him sitting amid representatives of some democratic faction who had the arrogance of thinking themselves the pinnacle of civilization. However, this 'civilization' (if it could be loosely translated as such) was no star-faring organization and so amounted to little in terms of galactic worth. It was a fact these people refused to see proclaiming their own ideals as something desirous to the galaxy at large.
After a day of arguing for a criminal's right to life, Zell had pretty much had it. As he knew it would, the real issue became buried in a quagmire of blowhard logic, emotionalism with not a little religious fanaticism thrown in for good measure.
As the representative of an advance space-faring society, he found himself under attack by these simpletons as they questioned the very fabric of, according to Zell, how the galaxy just worked.
A dark-haired man stood up pointing a finger at Zell, who sat rather unimpressed on a terrace above holding in his hand what passed as an alcoholic beverage on this world.
I pose this query:
Would you rather:
Execute 9 innocent men to ensure that one guilty man does not escape justice?
or
Let 9 guilty men go free (or perhaps, since we are dedicated to law and order, have them serve life sentences in prision) to ensure that the state not execute 1 innocent man?
Zell absently looked at his nails before turning his gaze at the one who posed the question. "Let me ask you this in return, do you want to live in a state where 100% of the guilty get justice or in a state where they don't?"
His gaze turned back to his nails, "I mean, if you are going to fucking let 9 guilty men go free or live the high life in prison getting their dicks sucked by lesser ones and being supported by your taxpayers then what the fuck do you have laws for?"
"..the innocents..."
Zell laughed. "The fucking innocents. Right. I could say something about why the innocents didn't get good fucking lawyers?...or, why, if they are innocent, did the truth of the matter not shine through for them? I mean, how can a lie stand up to the truth anyhow, eh? Or perhaps your fucking jury were so fucking apathetic that they couldn't have given a damn as to who was fucking innocent and who was guilty."
He spread his hands out, "But how does that fucking affect the punishment of crime? Because your fucking system of justice may have imprisoned an innocent person? Well, holy fucking shit! Change your damned system of justice so those fucking mistakes don't happen?! But no... your fucking democracies take the fucking lazy way out by blaming the punishment rather than the inequities of their system. Rather than actually work for your fucking better society, you'd rather drain your economies dry by claiming some higher fucking moral stand like mewling infants sucking the teet of your taxpayers!"
Another man dressed on blue shot up, forcefully pointing at Zell as if making a point, shouting...
Because study after study has shown that capital punishment does not work.
Because states with capital punishment have higher crime rates than those with.
Zell purred. "That's because, you dumbass, you obviously don't do it right. After not having to work a day in his life, Joe-criminal comes to a place that provides free lodging, free entertainment and free food ..and free dick sucking, I might add...You then give them the best damned meal they ever ate and then send them to their maker in their sleep using some injection method. I mean shit! Who the fuck would be scared by that? Perhaps you pussies maybe but not real fucking criminals!"
The shouting man rallied,
Because it has been proven countless times that capital punishment is a racially motivated form of punishment.
Zell leaned back, "In my experience, if you do the crime, you do the time." He looked around, "Or is that not what your system of justice is based upon?" He made the word justice sound like shit.
The shouting man went back to his old standby that he'd been spewing for a day and a half now..
Because there are many people on death row who are innocent, or who do not deserve the death penalty.
Zell gave the representatives an incredulous look, as if he could be further surprised by their incompetence, "Then fucking GET YOUR INNOCENT PEOPLE OFF OF DEATH ROW, asshole! THAT should be your fucking high minded cause. Not fucking reduced punishment for the guilty." He sat back, taking a sip of the weak-assed drink they provided and grimacing, "But no. If you remove the death penalty so that you lazy-ass bitches can sit back and salve your fucking consciences while letting your innocent continue to rot on death fucking row! Keep the fucking penalty! The outcry from your fucking innocents will get you off your lazy ass to actually do something and improve your broken justice system rather than maintaining the status-quo!"
Someone tried to bring up some religious excuse in support of the death penalty that Zell nearly spewed out his drink as he coughed at this turn of events.
Naturally, the weak defense was shot down and someone made the observation..
Anyways, I was just curious why so many Chrisitians are so vocally pro War and pro Capital Punishment. It's just never made sense to me.
The Imperial slammed his hand down. "That's got to be the single most brilliant thing I've heard all day!" He turned to the one that spoke, "But you will find that those with such religious tendencies will suddenly blur the line between what their supposed god wants and what they want when such issues arise. The dipshits never realize that politics and religion are not supposed to mix." he laughed out loud.
"Now see here!" someone shot up and Zell pointed a finger of his own. "God hates fucking before marriage, yes? He fucking hates fucking adultery too, yes?!"
"uhh.. yes." came a more timid reply.
"Then what punishment to the people would you presume to put forth for these infractions?"
"uhhh... well.. you see.."
"Well, what the fuck!?" Zell suddenly shouted angrily. "You were all tootin God's horn trying to defend your own stance on the Death Penalty (which is a weak assed defense in my book as it is) but now, you are unwilling to put your money where your faith is?! You would actually lead your fucking nation away from your fucking god by condoning something he hates?"
He grinned.
"Fucking hypocrites. If your fucking religion can't stay out of politics you are in the fucking wrong religion!"
"What's your religion!" someone shouted.
"Fucking common sense" he retorted. "And in that order! Fucking and common sense!"
Someone stood up to begin a dissertation on the lessons learned from the past, in favor of the death penalty, when the man in blue stood up again and condescended...
Now this is an interesting argument. Not because it has any real validity, but because it's ridiculous. It was done in ancient times, so it should be done today? People were killed for stealing in ancient times, that does not make it OK. African Americans were used as farm implements. Was that OK? Woman were denied education, jobs, and the right to vote. Was that OK?
"Well, I don't know..." Zell replied smoothly. "Perhaps that ancient system of justice actually punished the wrongdoer rather than both innocent and guilty like in your fucked up system! As for that other stuff, I don't know. I remember someone saying that you used to be able to leave the doors to your homes unlocked without fear. Now it seems that you all are fucked full of fear! And if that's
because you let your black humans off the farm and gave women education and the right to fucking vote, then shit! Put them back on the farm! Take away women's right to vote! And you certainly must have fucked up your woman's education!"
Zell narrowed his eyes, "Or could it be that despite some considered immoral actions back then, there
are kernels of wisdom to be learned from our past? Like the fucking death penalty!"
The man in blue chuckled.
I'm amused that you think mankind has gotten worse since those days. I'm sure your story would quickly change if you were forced to live in the conditions of the ancient world, with the daily threat of being killed by the sword, the plague, or, if you survived both of those, at the ripe old age of 40. The world really is a terrible place...
Zell suddenly gave a feral grin, his eyes flashing dangerously, "Oh yes. You must think that because you can drink water from a sink rather than a pond, you are civilized and therefore better. You think because you use a gun rather than a bow and arrow you are better?! You must think that this.." he waved his hand around, "is utopia-aplenty! This society of pussies that cry over spilt milk rather than fucking cleaning it up. This fucking society that seems to condescend the past when a man was a man and when he lived or died by his own merits and not the bullshit that spills from his mouth! Back when you took your chances and died with the knowledge that you had done all you could for yourself and yours! Oh no... it's certainly not like now..
Where your unemployed and homeless live in squalor. This fucking rich faction that can't provide even the most basic of medical care for it's citizenry because they can't fucking afford it! This fucking rich faction that can't fucking pay it's civil servants, much less push their criminal element, to even clean their fucking streets! I've toured your cities! I've seen your fucking garbage and filth that is scattered by the wind as an apathetic citizenry simply stares at it as if it's the fucking neatest thing since boiled water! Where your fucking children are so fucking..
weak! that they shy away from any sort of responsibility. These welps you go to great lengths to protect from the experiences of life...experiences that ancient children met with fucking balls while yours are pandered too by dancing stuffed animals! Where your fucking kids don't know where to stick their dicks until they're twenty and have fucking bastards trailing them from region to region wondering when the world will give them a fucking handout because you've trained them to expect it! Where they will end up in a deadbeat job working for some bastard that will fire them before their fucking retirement is due because he's a religious prick and then live out the rest of his days in a home for forgotten seniors where they can be abused by the staff and treated with the same lack of respect they gave to their elders! Yes, asshole, life after fucking 40 looks really bright in your fucking imaginary world! I pity those that live after 40 here!
Mankind has gotten worse. They've gone soft thinking the world...thinking the galaxy owes them fucking dinner on a platter. In fact, your criminal element is the only thing that
is working for his supper and you fucking encourage them by pandering to them. You are a bunch of spoiled fucking pussies that should, quite frankly, feed your rapists and murders and keep them healthy so they can be around to put you out of your fucking misery in the end!"
The man in blue looked around as burning eyes of Azrael Zell stared down from his seated position.
After a moment, the representative continued soflty, (and some would say, stupidly)
But the point is that right now, today, killing is wrong. That's why we have laws against it.
Another spoke up,
Most people would (I think) condone killing another human even if you have to say "they're coming at you, and the only way you can defend yourself is to kill them".
The man in blue retorted,
But that's not what we're talking about here. Self defense is another matter entirely. We're talking about killing someone after the fact, so that the victims of the crime can feel some satisfaction. That's not justice, it's revenge, and revenge has no place in a courtroom.
Zell frowned, "How is it fucking revenge when the guilty bastard is put to death five fucking years or more after the fact of his crime! Your fucking legal system crawls slower than a fucking bantha!"
He turned to the man in blue, "What I don't get is why you are decrying the death penalty on this fucking morality charge... Killing is wrong?? Tell me, where's your fucking soap box decrying your country's military? It is, I believe, an institution that thrives on killing is it not? Where's your outrage at the existence of bomb manufacturers?"
"Bombs don't kill people. People kill people.." came a weak voice.
"Who the fuck said that fucking nonsense?!" Zell barked out. "I'll fucking show you the death a bomb can deliver!"
Turning to the man in blue, "Well, asshole. What's it going to be? You say killing is wrong and then you say it's ok if it's self defense...so you are already wavering like a fucking pussy!"
He leaned forward, "Tell me you prick, if a person has a right to self defense by killing, does not a society have a right to it's self defense by killing that which would rip it asunder if left to feed off it like a parasite?"
The man in blue gave the heart of his arguement then..
Only if you assume that you have the right to decide if a person deserves to live or die. I don't think that's a right mankind has or deserves.
Zell stood there quietly as the chamber fell silent. His frown had turned into a scowl and, quite honestly, he had heard enough.
"Allow me to tell you, then, who
does have that right." he stated matter of factly into the silence.
And with a firm voice, "Those that
take it!"
"You need to shed your fucking wimpering skepticism and realize that killing is a right that only your criminal element is seizing and unless you man up, unless you reach deep down for your firm resolve, grab your balls and your sword and stand firmly in their path, they are going to run you over like the pussies that you are.
Despite your shiny-happy-people outlook on life, this galaxy is a most dangerous place. And if you are not man enough to face it and face reality and actually make the fucking hard decisions in life like who to kill and who not too kill, then you doom the next generation into making the same pussy mistakes you do."
He smirked, "And if you are so fucking concerned about your innocent dipshits on death row.."
He leaned forward, "THEN FIX YOUR FUCKING LEGAL SYSTEM!"
[SIZE=1]Note: Quotes taken from Rebel Cafe Discussion:
Travesty of Justice[/SIZE]