By the way, Ceel is copying everything said in this thread over into his "more geniuses that hate us" thread on TGC.
We don't hate the rp'ers on TGC. We don't even know half of them.
But realistically, knocking the whole TGC/Ceel problem out of the picture for a moment (which means there's no need for reconciliation), and focus on the 'unity' aspect, does a revitalization necessarily require boards giving up their identity in favor of a "super board" the way SWFans was way back when?
Besides having affiliate links which people may or may not view, (and keep in mind I am no where near the surfer most others are like Ahnk, Gue and Sam) but I've seen webrings linking like boards before.
Do these work?
A central portal for Star Wars Roleplaying and then linking each "galaxy" board equally?
Each board offers something different and unique and each has their good and bad points. The choice really is up to the lurker and what tickles their fancy.